What do we tell our boys about what it is to be a man? Often, the answer is a long list of toxic traits. We should not be surprised by the results.
A constant, pervasive drumbeat tells boys and young men that certain behaviours and attitudes are inherently male. The bleak outcomes facing today's young men - in suicide, addiction, joblessness, academic failure and radicalisation - are the predictable consequence of a culture comfortable with these crass generalisations.
The answer is not, as the manosphere would have boys believe, to blame feminism. It is to learn from it. Feminism gave women clearly defined and fiercely defended rules for what a woman is not. We need the same for men.
What a Man Is Not sets out a vision of masculinity that rejects bleak and toxic worldviews. It makes a passionate case for the boys we are losing - and offers a practical, optimistic plan for getting them back.
"Careful, evidenced, and unsparing - the book on masculinity for people who want to think rather than be reassured." - Polly Mackenzie
"The next step in thinking about the sexes." - Danny Dorling, author of Seven Children: Inequality and Britain's Next Generation
"This book offers a clarion call for a new masculinity: one that tells boys and young men that they do not have to copy the pathetic anti-female antics of the Andrew Tates of this world or believe in crude assertions of male superiority. The data and arguments presented in this excellent book show clearly how girls and boys, men and women, can actually work together against overt and covert discriminations and stereotypes and all can become better human beings." - Sally Tomlinson, co-author of Rule Britannia
"It takes a brave man to wade into the gender wars, let alone to make a detailed argument both that men behave badly and that they are discriminated against. Harry Carr is that man. In the best sense of the words What A Man Is Not is truly thought provoking. Not everyone will agree with him but they should read the potent and erudite case he makes for how the sexes could do things better." - Adam Boulton
"A wise and enjoyable book that melts away hyper-masculinity." - Polly Toynbee
"Harry Carr makes the persuasive, but too little heard, argument that countering male stereotypes will make the world fairer, more meritocratic and safer for everyone. He reminds us that tackling boys' under achievement in schools and supporting men's mental and physical health need not come at the price of progress for women,. The binary opposition of masculinity and femininity espoused by social media influencers and promoted through social media algorithms might generate clicks, but they don't make for good public policy or happy productive humans. We should all read this book - parents, teachers, employers - to ensure that we're not inadvertently boxing young men into a cold lonely place." - Rosie Campbell, former director of the Global Institute for Women’s Leadership
"A striking and clear-eyed account of the challenges facing too many boys and men. Harry Carr poses questions our politics has too often ducked - and provides provocative answers all sides will need to grapple with." - Alistair Strathern MP, Co-Chair of Labour Group for Boys and Men
"Taking men's pain seriously could help us rethink our understandings of sexual difference and counter the ongoing orchestration of men's discontent by reactionary forces. An important text for these times." - Lynne Segal, author of Lean on Me: A Politics of Radical Care
"An unsettling yet humane account, written with real compassion for both men and women. I was left with a well of sadness for my son and for generations of young men whose pain has been sidelined - but also optimism that change is possible." - Mary Curnock Cook CBE, former CEO of UCAS
"A really engaging invitation to reflect on yours and others' ideas on 'maleness' ... rich food for thought." - Duncan Craig OBE, CEO of We Are Survivors
"A fascinating, data-driven exploration of why men are falling behind in the modern world - and why feminism holds the answers for helping them." - Stephen Bush
"A searing addition to the growing pantheon of writers addressing the issues facing men and boys. A unique perspective that moves the conversation forward with vigour." - Mark Brooks, Centre for Policy Research on Men and Boys
"Passionate and reasoned in an area that often stirs the passions but passes reason by." - Philip Collins, editor of Prospect
"In a world of men often being not great, this gives you hope. It is warm, kind and funny - Harry Carr is one of the good guys." - Max Rushden
